GS 2
Why is the Kerch Bridge attack significant?
Relevance: GS 2 International Relations
Context: The Kerch Bridge, linking the Russian mainland to the Crimean Peninsula, was attacked by two Ukrainian sea drones.
Importance of Kerch Bridge:
- The bridge is crucial for Russia, providing a logistical supply link for its troops in the south.
- After annexing Crimea in 2014, Russia lacked direct connectivity between the mainland and Crimea, prompting the construction of the bridge.
- Ukraine targeted the bridge during its planned offensive to retake Kherson, aiming to disrupt Russian supplies and secure a land bridge for Crimea.
Ukraine’s Counteroffensive:
- Ukraine launched a counteroffensive using advanced weapons supplied by the West.
- The U.S. and European allies provided various military aid packages, including armaments and training.
- Despite some territorial gains in the southeast, Ukraine hasn’t achieved a breakthrough victory.
- The counteroffensive faced challenges due to well-fortified Russian positions and significant weaponry losses for Ukraine.
Pressure on Ukraine:
- Ukraine received assurances of further weapons and training from Western allies during the NATO summit in Vilnius, Lithuania.
- Ukraine’s major thrust in the counteroffensive was yet to begin before the attack on the Kerch Bridge.
Should delimitation be delayed further?
Relevance: Indian Constitution- historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.
Context: Delimitation process
Background and Delimitation History:
- Delimitation involves redrawing boundaries of Lok Sabha and State Assembly constituencies based on Census data to achieve almost equal voter representation.
- Last delimitation exercise took place in 1976, using 1971 Census data.
- A freeze was placed on delimitation until the first Census after 2026 due to population imbalances between northern and southern states.
- Current Lok Sabha boundaries are based on the 2001 Census, but the number of seats remains frozen based on the 1971 Census.
Delimitation Process and Parliament’s Role:
- Parliament specifies the total number of Lok Sabha and Legislative Assembly seats.
- Delimitation Commission, appointed under a Delimitation Commission Act, redistributes seats among states based on population.
- Parliament can make exceptional arrangements for specific cases, but the principle of one person, one vote, and one value cannot be eliminated.
Regional Variations in Population Trends:
- Population count shows demographic divergence between northern and southern states.
- Suggestions for a fixed proportionality in representation based on population, with room for deviation in specific circumstances.
- Representation should also consider the voices of marginalized communities, like tribal people and the elderly.
Balancing Representation and Marginal Voices:
- Representation should not solely be based on headcount, but also consider characteristics of representation.
- Political decisions and negotiations will determine the final formula for representation.
- The process should not introduce colonial concepts of different categories of voters.
Concerns of Southern States and Impact of Migration:
- Some calculations suggest that redistribution of seats according to current population distribution may impact the representation of northern and southern states.
- Migration patterns show significant mobility from the east to the south and from the north to the west.
- Migrants’ agency is becoming increasingly important in political outcomes, and candidates are addressing migrant-related issues in elections.
In impasse in wrestlers’ case, the loser is the rule of law
Context: Women trainee wrestlers, including award-winning sportspersons, faced alleged sexual advances and indignities during training for almost a decade.
Background:
- The rule of law and autonomy cannot be taken for granted; it depends on political commitment and a robust rule of law culture.
- Contemporary Indian society faces weakening of the rule of law due to a trust deficit in the colonial model of the rule of law and a faith-oriented majoritarian re-imagination of laws.
Case of Wrestlers’ Alleged Sexual Harassment:
- In January 2023, they began a sit-in protest at Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, seeking resolution.
- The Sports Ministry referred the complaints to an oversight committee, but no satisfactory outcome was achieved.
- The wrestlers approached the Supreme Court, leading to the registration of FIRs under relevant laws and judicial oversight.
- The alleged perpetrator, a politician in a top sports position, started a vilification campaign against the wrestlers.
- Slothful and Selective Investigation:
- Delhi Police took time in investigating the crime and focused on the complainants’ credentials while being lenient towards the accused.
- The police filed a closure application under the POCSO Act based on the withdrawal application of a minor wrestler, raising questions about police selectivity.
Rule of Law Course Correction:
- The rule of law requires universal and equal applicability, ensuring a fair and impartial investigation.
- Judicial oversight is crucial to check police powers and monitor the investigation.
- Survivors’ protests for justice have not yielded adequate relief, raising concerns about the weakening of the rule of law in the country.
- The need is to stand up and resort to course correction to save the soul of the rule of law.
Broader Context:
- Similar threats to the rule of law are faced in other democracies worldwide.
- The Stockholm Criminology Symposium highlighted the theme of principled and equitable law enforcement.
India’s data protection law needs refinement
Context: India’s Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Bill, 2022 is likely to be tabled in Parliament, but critical gaps remain.
Introduction:
- Drafting a data protection law for over 1.4 billion Indians is challenging.
- The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) has faced implementation challenges and risks being ineffective.
Scope and Definition:
- The DPDP Bill only protects personal data, leaving out non-personal data.
- Non-personal data, when combined with other datasets, can lead to identification and privacy risks.
- The previous drafts accounted for this, but the latest version lacks provisions for penalizing re-identification of non-personal data as personal data.
Limited Reach of Data Protection Board:
- The proposed data protection board cannot initiate proceedings on its own.
- Users have limited control and knowledge of data transfers, making it difficult for them to approach the board.
- Allowing the board to take action on behalf of affected users would be beneficial.
Solutions for Implementation Challenges:
- Including penalties for re-identification of non-personal data as personal data would enhance the scope and effectiveness of the DPDP Bill.
- Allowing the data protection board to initiate complaints on its own would provide better enforcement capabilities.
Future-Proof Legislation:
- Addressing the gaps in the DPDP Bill will improve its implementation and ensure it remains relevant in the rapidly evolving data economy.
GS 3
SC asks Centre to transfer cheetahs to other location
Context: The court urged the government to consider moving the remaining cheetahs to a more suitable environment if needed and not turn the issue into a “prestige” matter.
Disturbing Cheetah Mortality Rates at Kuno National Park:
- Within a year, 40% of the 20 cheetahs brought from South Africa and Namibia to Kuno National Park (KNP) have died, raising serious concerns.
- Eight cheetahs have died in a short span, with two deaths occurring just last week.
- Alarming cheetah mortality rates indicate a precarious situation for the translocated big cats.
Supreme Court Urges Relocation:
- The Supreme Court advised the Union government to consider moving the cheetahs to a more suitable environment, if necessary.
- The welfare and survival of the cheetahs should take precedence over any prestige associated with the conservation project.
Centre’s Response and Measures:
- The Additional Solicitor General acknowledged the unfortunate deaths of the cheetahs and attributed them to several reasons.
- The cheetah conservation project is considered prestigious, and authorities are exploring various options to ensure the well-being and survival of the remaining cheetahs at Kuno National Park.
- The Centre assures that efforts are being made to address the situation and protect the cheetahs.
Centre bans export of non-basmati white rice to control price rise in India
Context: The Directorate General of Foreign Trade, under the Union Commerce Ministry, announced an immediate ban on the export of non-basmati white rice.
Reasons for the Ban:
- The ban was implemented to ensure sufficient availability of non-basmati white rice in the domestic market and to curb price rise.
- Retail prices had increased by 11.5% over a year and 3% over the past month, necessitating measures to stabilize prices.
Previous Measures and Their Impact:
- Export duty of 20% on non-basmati white rice was imposed earlier to lower prices and ensure availability in the domestic market.
- However, despite the imposition of export duty, exports of this rice variety increased significantly.
- Factors contributing to the surge in exports include high international prices due to geopolitical scenarios, El Nino sentiments, and extreme climatic conditions in other rice-producing countries.
Impact on Exports:
- In 2023-24, about 15.54 lakh tonnes of non-basmati white rice were exported, compared to only 11.55 lakh tonnes during 2022-23.
- The sharp increase in exports has been attributed to various external factors impacting rice prices in the global market.